i think if you made the blue a little less blue it would be perfect

Black and white reigns!

I'm stuck.

The black and white one brings out the sadness and makes the picture own a BILLION words, like as if she was said because of memories.

Yet the blue one shows just how truelly gorgeous it is, and also brings out an element of seeing it magically...

I just can't decided ^^'

I happen to like the blue It makes the kitten seem sad and gorgeous but then I'm biased. Blue is my favourite colour

it depends what you want people to feel when they see the photo. If you want a sense of sadness and hopelessness to occur in the viewer, then the first one (black and white) would be better. The blue picture also triggers a sense of saddness but not as intense as the first. And that is because in my opinion, because of the cat's eyes. In the B&W, it's eyes are completely bland because of the lack of color. But in the blue one, it's eyes are a beautiful and vibrant blue.
Sorry i wrote a whole paragraph to answer your "?"
I choose the Blue one

I took a long time to make a choice : the B&W one seems more expressive, more touching. But I finally voted for the blue one, just because of the beautiful eyes… Maybe you can find a way to combine the two, like lowering saturation on the whole picture, except the eyes. But it would look artificial, and I'm not actually good at giving such advice after all

I love both of them! I cant decide!

I don't know.. I like bouth of them, on the blue one it's like .. what shall i say.. fantasy thing over it,(VERY beutifull) and tha gray one locks kind of old..Very nice bouth